Benefits BrokerAtlas

Benefits brokers in Indianapolis, IN

101 benefits brokers in Indianapolis — 101 named on at least two 2024 Form 5500 filings. Most plan filings first. This is not a ranking of quality or price.

Health and welfare plans (89)Retirement plans (16)Median plan under 200 participants (37)Median plan 200 to 999 participants (57)Median plan 1,000+ participants (7)Fees reported as well as commissions (60)
Featured spots · Indianapolis, IN

Feature your benefits broker on the Indianapolis, IN page

Reach employers and plan sponsors comparing benefits brokers and agents searching in Indianapolis, IN. Labelled placement above the list, your description and website, and messages sent straight to you.

3 of 3 spots open
$249/month
Claim a spotFlat fee · no per-lead charges · cancel anytime

All benefits brokers

Img2960 North Meridian Street · Indianapolis, IN 46208 · Health and welfare plans1,344 plan filings · $1,734,192 disclosed · median 504 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsApex Benefits Group, INC.9400 Priority Way West Drive · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans69 plan filings · $4,088,178 disclosed · median 225 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsFirst Person, INC8900 Keystone Crossing, Suite 900 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans69 plan filings · $2,293,430 disclosed · median 216 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsHylant Group INC10401 North Meridian Street, Suite 200 · Indianapolis, IN 46290 · Health and welfare plans49 plan filings · $1,398,108 disclosed · median 267 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsLocascio Hadden & Dennis LLC250 West 96th Street, Suite 350 · Indianapolis, IN 46260 · Health and welfare plans43 plan filings · $1,210,861 disclosed · median 238 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsLocascio Hadden & Dennis, LLC401 Pennsylvania Parkway, Suite 200 · Indianapolis, IN 46280 · Health and welfare plans43 plan filings · $1,844,048 disclosed · median 216 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsThe Rose Financial Group, LLC6602 East 75th St., Suite 200 · Indianapolis, IN 46250 · Retirement plans34 plan filings · $212,731 disclosed · median 154 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGregory & Appel, INC.1402 North Capitol, Suite 400 · Indianapolis, IN 46202 · Health and welfare plans30 plan filings · $1,853,559 disclosed · median 282 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAnthem Insurance Companies, INC.120 Monument Circle · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Health and welfare plans27 plan filings · $44,986 disclosed · median 417 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsElizabeth Louise Fender335 S Emerson Ave · Indianapolis, IN 46219 · Health and welfare plans18 plan filings · $3,321 disclosed · median 288 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filings
Gregory & Appel, INC.1402 N Capitol, Suite 400 · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Health and welfare plans18 plan filings · $941,834 disclosed · median 177 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGregory a McRoberts900 E 96th St Ste 300 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans18 plan filings · $5,277 disclosed · median 364 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsIndianapolis300 North Meridian Street, Suite 1720 · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Retirement plans17 plan filings · $3,852 disclosed · median 135 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsConner Health and Benefits, INC.8445 Keystone Crossing Boulevard, Suite 200 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans14 plan filings · $917,795 disclosed · median 614 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsOni Risk Partners INCPO Box 80159 · Indianapolis, IN 46280 · Health and welfare plans12 plan filings · $535,824 disclosed · median 131 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsOni Risk Partners, INC600 E 96th St, Ste 400 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans11 plan filings · $202,535 disclosed · median 274 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsFirst Person Benefit Advisors8900 Keystone Crossing, Suite 900 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans9 plan filings · $396,870 disclosed · median 161 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsIcul Services CorporationPO Box 50425 · Indianapolis, IN 46250 · Health and welfare plans9 plan filings · $499,280 disclosed · median 187 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsErtel & Company, INC.10945 Cork Place · Indianapolis, IN 46236 · Health and welfare plans8 plan filings · $192,828 disclosed · median 124 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsIndiana Chamber Ins. Agency, INC.115 West Washington Street, Suite 850s · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Health and welfare plans8 plan filings · $6,667 disclosed · median 176 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsRogle INC7460 Lantern Road · Indianapolis, IN 46256 · Health and welfare plans8 plan filings · $117,569 disclosed · median 555 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAmerican United LifeUnknown · Indianapolis, IN 46206 · Health and welfare plans7 plan filings · $105,984 disclosed · median 161 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsBenefit Innovations LLP9755 Randall Drive, Suite 101 · Indianapolis, IN 46280 · Health and welfare plans7 plan filings · $342,508 disclosed · median 208 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGallagher Benefit Services, INC.1075 Broad Ripple Road, Suite 268 · Indianapolis, IN 46220 · Health and welfare plans7 plan filings · $83,736 disclosed · median 132 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAssuredpartnersPO Box 90380 · Indianapolis, IN 46290 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $63,469 disclosed · median 150 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsCompensation Systems INC900 E. 96th Street, Suite 325 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Retirement plans6 plan filings · $49,108 disclosed · median 299 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGregory & Appel Insurance433 North Capitol, Suite 400 · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $58,365 disclosed · median 193 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsHorizon Planning Group9000 Keystone Crossing · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $416 disclosed · median 127 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsIndianapolis Regional Office300 North Meridian Street, Suite 1720 · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Retirement plans6 plan filings · $1,687 disclosed · median 309 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsLhd Benefit Advisors250 West 96th St., Ste 300 · Indianapolis, IN 46260 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $126,335 disclosed · median 189 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsMj Insurance INC9225 Priority Way West Drive, Suite 100 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $108,747 disclosed · median 352 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsRick McPherson6352 Marburn Dr · Indianapolis, IN 46227 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $2,147 disclosed · median 126 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsSteele Ins. & Financial Svcs., INC.9020 Crawfordsville Road · Indianapolis, IN 46234 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $173,729 disclosed · median 398 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsUnited Benefit Advisors INC280 E. 96th Street, Ste 250 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $0 disclosed · median 246 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAssuredpartners9247 North Meridian Street, Suite 200 · Indianapolis, IN 46260 · Health and welfare plans5 plan filings · $98,975 disclosed · median 133 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsIndy Chamber LLC111 Monument Circle, Suite 1950 · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Health and welfare plans5 plan filings · $3,985 disclosed · median 183 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsLocascio Hadden & Dennis LLC10585 North Meridian Street, Suite 275 · Indianapolis, IN 46290 · Health and welfare plans5 plan filings · $145,151 disclosed · median 160 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAon Risk Services Central INC.450 East 96th St., Suite 275 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $50,800 disclosed · median 149 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsCapstone Benefits Group INC6110 Technology Center Dr #500 · Indianapolis, IN 46278 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $21,735 disclosed · median 288 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGregory & Appel Insurance1402 N Capitol Ste 400 · Indianapolis, IN 46202 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $103,100 disclosed · median 394 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsIndiana Chamber Insurance Agency115 West Washington Street,, Suite 850s · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $2,018 disclosed · median 189 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsIntegrity Benefit Partners, INC9511 Angola CT Ste 263 · Indianapolis, IN 46268 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $18,560 disclosed · median 140 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsJ.d. Resley Associates INC8900 Keystone Crossing, 560 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $150,899 disclosed · median 469 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsJennifer L Mitchen9247 N Meridian St Ste 205 · Indianapolis, IN 46260 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $11 disclosed · median 192 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsLinc Holdings, LLC601 S Meridian St., Ste 500 · Indianapolis, IN 46225 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $41,952 disclosed · median 196 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsOne America Securities, INC.One American Square, PO Box 1984 · Indianapolis, IN 46206 · Retirement plans4 plan filings · $47,683 disclosed · median 258 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsPeter J Emmert5904 Oakforge Ln · Indianapolis, IN 46254 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $288 disclosed · median 192 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAmerican Healthcare Group, INC.3939 Priority Way South Drive, Suite 250 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $21,458 disclosed · median 161 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAmerican Pension Advisors, LTD9265 Counselors Row Ste 105 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Retirement plans3 plan filings · $1,272 disclosed · median 128 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsBernard Health LLC2817 West End Avenue, Suite 126-281 · Indianapolis, IN 46220 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $3,974 disclosed · median 21 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsCapstone Benefit Group INC6110 Technology Center Dr #500 · Indianapolis, IN 46278 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $14,262 disclosed · median 855 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsEbc INC.PO Box 55210 · Indianapolis, IN 46220 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $2,813 disclosed · median 607 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsFifth Third Insurance Agency INC8335 Keystone Xing, Ste 106 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $5,615 disclosed · median 189 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsImg2960 North Meridian Street · Indianapolis, IN 46206 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $119 disclosed · median 220 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsKatie J. Fletcher9247 North Meridian · Indianapolis, IN 46260 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $1,384 disclosed · median 411 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsKey Benefit Administrators8330 Allison Pointe Trail · Indianapolis, IN 46250 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $181,251 disclosed · median 334 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsKiecker Corporation600 E 96th St Ste 100 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $983 disclosed · median 102 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsMj Insurance INC.PO Box 50435 · Indianapolis, IN 46250 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $54,704 disclosed · median 181 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsNefouse & Associates, INC.8435 Keystone Crossing, Suite 160 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $128,877 disclosed · median 328 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsOni Risk Partners, INCPO Box 2364 · Indianapolis, IN 46206 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $64,752 disclosed · median 444 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsSteele Insurance and Fin. Svcs. INC9020 Crawfordsville Road · Indianapolis, IN 46234 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $58,235 disclosed · median 297 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsSteele Insurance and Financial9020 Crawfordsville Road · Indianapolis, IN 46234 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $43,234 disclosed · median 419 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsTimothy B Asby9247 North Meridian Street, Suite 205 · Indianapolis, IN 46260 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $191 disclosed · median 343 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAssured Partners of Indiana LLC10401 N Meridian St, Ste 300 · Indianapolis, IN 46290 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $103,781 disclosed · median 2,882 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAssuredpartners of Indiana LLC9247 N Merdian St, Suite 200 · Indianapolis, IN 46260 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $105,245 disclosed · median 638 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsBh Group In, LLCBroad Ripple Avenue, Suite 268 · Indianapolis, IN 46220 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $2,825 disclosed · median 123 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsCapstone Administrators LLC6110 Technology Center Dr, Suite 500 · Indianapolis, IN 46278 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $21,743 disclosed · median 703 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsEpic Insurance MidwestPO Box 80159 · Indianapolis, IN 46280 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $16,219 disclosed · median 147 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGallagher Benefit Services, INC.PO Box 40948 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $234,132 disclosed · median 4,447 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGallagher Benefit Svcs INCPO Box 40948 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $479,388 disclosed · median 5,825 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGregory & Appel INC Lacey Robinson1402 N Capitol Ave Ste 400 · Indianapolis, IN 46202 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $17,772 disclosed · median 507 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGregory McRoberts900 E 96th St Ste 300 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $0 disclosed · median 825 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsImb2960 North Meridian Street · Indianapolis, IN 46208 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $149 disclosed · median 324 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsIndiana Chamber Insurance Agency in115 West Washington Street, Suite 850s · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $964 disclosed · median 205 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsInspire Workforce of Kentucky888 Keystone Crossing · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $102,592 disclosed · median 609 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsJames J Newett6933 Flick Drive · Indianapolis, IN 46237 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $39,320 disclosed · median 411 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsJd Resley Associates, INC.8900 Keystone Crossing, Suite 560 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $74,459 disclosed · median 18,115 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsJimmy a LutherPO Box 50619 · Indianapolis, IN 46250 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $49,819 disclosed · median 211 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsJohn Resley8900 Keystone Crossing, Suite 560 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $2,309 disclosed · median 469 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsKey Benefit Administrators, INC.8330 Allison Pointe Trail · Indianapolis, IN 46226 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $6,809 disclosed · median 209 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsKey Benefits Administrators8330 Allison Pointe Trail · Indianapolis, IN 46250 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $34,608 disclosed · median 496 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsMaria N Vondielingen9912 Ridge Dr · Indianapolis, IN 46256 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $122 disclosed · median 292 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsMcGowan Benefits Group, LLC355 Indianta Avenue, Suite 200 · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $57,457 disclosed · median 161 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsMcGowan Insurance Group, LLC355 Indiana Avenue, Suite 200 · Indianapolis, IN 46204 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $47,531 disclosed · median 331 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsMichael C Carter1313 Lake Meadow Dr · Indianapolis, IN 46217 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $4,177 disclosed · median 328 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsMml Insurance Agency LLC900 E 96th St Ste 300 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Retirement plans2 plan filings · $9,157 disclosed · median 200 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsNefouse & Assoc INC8435 Keystone Crossing, Suite 160 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $29,575 disclosed · median 114 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsOnboard Benefits LLC9020 Crawfordsville Road · Indianapolis, IN 46234 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $23,091 disclosed · median 434 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsOneamerica Securities INC.One American Square, PO Box 368 · Indianapolis, IN 46206 · Retirement plans2 plan filings · $21,645 disclosed · median 271 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsOneamerica Securities, INC.One American Square, P.o. Box 368 · Indianapolis, IN 46282 · Retirement plans2 plan filings · $20,242 disclosed · median 259 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsOni Risk Partners INC600 E 96th St, Ste 400 · Indianapolis, IN 46420 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $16,099 disclosed · median 139 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsPeter Emigh900 E 96th St. Ste 300 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Retirement plans2 plan filings · $34,262 disclosed · median 110 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsSanctuary Securities INC3815 River Crossing Pkwy Ste 200 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Retirement plans2 plan filings · $10,229 disclosed · median 80,584 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsSpectrum Source Brokerage9535 East 59th Street, Suite C · Indianapolis, IN 46216 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $200,533 disclosed · median 1,215 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsSteele Ins & Financial Services INC9020 Crawfordsville Road · Indianapolis, IN 46234 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $93,685 disclosed · median 500 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsSteele Insurance and Financial Svcs9020 Crawfordsville Road · Indianapolis, IN 46234 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $38,836 disclosed · median 536 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsSusan Marie Bard7219 Derstain Road · Indianapolis, IN 46250 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $3,678 disclosed · median 430 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsTurnkey Benefit Insurance Services8330 Allison Point Trail, Ste 200 · Indianapolis, IN 46250 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $57,481 disclosed · median 627 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsVincent Saul900 E 96th St Ste 300 · Indianapolis, IN 46240 · Retirement plans2 plan filings · $34,262 disclosed · median 110 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsWalkerhughes Group, LLC6510 N. Shadeland Avenue · Indianapolis, IN 46220 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $56,099 disclosed · median 18,025 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filings
Comparing benefits brokers in Indianapolis? Ask each for a written description of every way it is paid, and read questions to ask your benefits broker.

Listed from DOL EBSA Form 5500 datasets — Schedule A Part 1, DOL EBSA Form 5500 datasets — Form 5500, DOL EFAST2 Form 5500 search. Order: most plan filings first — not a quality or price ranking — never paid. Is something wrong? Tell us.