Benefits BrokerAtlas

Benefits brokers in Carmel, IN

44 benefits brokers in Carmel — 44 named on at least two 2024 Form 5500 filings. Most plan filings first. This is not a ranking of quality or price.

Health and welfare plans (42)Retirement plans (4)Median plan under 200 participants (13)Median plan 200 to 999 participants (27)Median plan 1,000+ participants (4)Fees reported as well as commissions (33)
Featured spots · Carmel, IN

Feature your benefits broker on the Carmel, IN page

Reach employers and plan sponsors comparing benefits brokers and agents searching in Carmel, IN. Labelled placement above the list, your description and website, and messages sent straight to you.

3 of 3 spots open
$249/month
Claim a spotFlat fee · no per-lead charges · cancel anytime

All benefits brokers

Mj InsurancePO Box 3430 · Carmel, IN 46082 · Health and welfare plans134 plan filings · $4,988,374 disclosed · median 238 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsMj Insurance571 Monon Boulevard, Suite 400 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans132 plan filings · $6,619,984 disclosed · median 304 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGallagher Benefit Services, INC.650 East Carmel Drive, Suite 400 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans91 plan filings · $9,025,839 disclosed · median 837 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsShepherd Insurance LLC111 Congressional Boulevard, Suite 100 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans56 plan filings · $2,315,515 disclosed · median 210 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsHoward J Horowitz2610 Alcott Street · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans53 plan filings · $26,883 disclosed · median 255 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAmerican Healthcare Group, INC.11555 North Meridian Street, Suite 530 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans36 plan filings · $1,517,187 disclosed · median 203 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsBrown and Brown of Indiana, INC.11595 North Meridian Street, Suite 250 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans16 plan filings · $509,316 disclosed · median 148 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAssuredpartners10 East Main Street, Suite 400 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans13 plan filings · $292,387 disclosed · median 145 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsUsi Insurance Services LLC11611 North Meridian Street, Suite 230 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans13 plan filings · $334,130 disclosed · median 190 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsBrandon Marcello Cento13816 Fernleaf Way · Carmel, IN 46033 · Health and welfare plans12 plan filings · $304 disclosed · median 303 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filings
M J InsurancePO Box 3430 · Carmel, IN 46082 · Health and welfare plans11 plan filings · $238,036 disclosed · median 435 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsJohn T Clancy4025 Pete Dye Blvd · Carmel, IN 46033 · Health and welfare plans9 plan filings · $9,242 disclosed · median 222 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsRobert W. Burgett3670 West 141st Street · Carmel, IN 46074 · Health and welfare plans7 plan filings · $5,530 disclosed · median 391 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAmerican Health and Wellness Group11555 North Meridian Street, Suite 530 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $194,498 disclosed · median 180 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsEpic Insurance Midwest11711 N Meridian St, Suite 700 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $174,110 disclosed · median 121 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsHylant Group INC10401 North Meridian Street, Suite 200 · Carmel, IN 46280 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $53,359 disclosed · median 226 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsJames R. Julian2264 Glebe Street · Carmel, IN 46032 · Retirement plans6 plan filings · $13,931 disclosed · median 12 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsKevin F Ward12632 Double Eagle Dr · Carmel, IN 46033 · Health and welfare plans6 plan filings · $104 disclosed · median 235 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAaron Vanpelt INC11495 Pennsylvania St, Ste 200 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans5 plan filings · $23,442 disclosed · median 353 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAssuredpartners of Indiana LLC10 East Main Street, Suite 400 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans5 plan filings · $90,330 disclosed · median 684 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsHoward Horowitz2610 Alcott St · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans5 plan filings · $662 disclosed · median 404 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGbs Administrators, INC.10 W. Carmel Dr. Suite 260 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $438,043 disclosed · median 5,328 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsHoffman Benefit Services484 E Carmel Dr Ste 103 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $150,286 disclosed · median 31 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsJeffrey D Brindle10811 Lakeview Drive · Carmel, IN 46033 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $2,224 disclosed · median 214 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsOni Risk Partners, INC11711 N Meridian St Ste 700 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans4 plan filings · $59,226 disclosed · median 175 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsAmerican Healthcare Group, INC.Two Penn Mark Plaza, 11555 N Meridian Street Ste 530 · Carmel, IN 46033 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $120,120 disclosed · median 165 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsBlue Benefits Consulting, INC.12800 N. Meridian Street · Carmel, IN 46032 · Retirement plans3 plan filings · $11,485 disclosed · median 174 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsBrown & Brown of Tennessee INC11595 N Meridian Street, Suite 250 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $1,708 disclosed · median 113 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsBrown and Brown Insurance Services11595 N. Meridian Ave, Suite 250 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $45,026 disclosed · median 946 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsHolly Renee Ashley720 South Ridgeline Road, Apartment 419 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $369 disclosed · median 413 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsMj Ins INCPO Box 3430 · Carmel, IN 46082 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $78,763 disclosed · median 627 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsOptavise LLC11825 North Penn Street · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $223,004 disclosed · median 204 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsRobert Wayne Burgett3670 W 141st St · Carmel, IN 46074 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $88 disclosed · median 940 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsShepherd Insurance LLC (Nfp)111 Congressional Boulevard · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans3 plan filings · $80,171 disclosed · median 404 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsBrown & Brown Insurance Svcs., INC.11595 North Meridian Street, Suite 250 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $22,664 disclosed · median 345 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsCarly L Kierce13932 Wilmuth Dr · Carmel, IN 46074 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $1,392 disclosed · median 126 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsDetrude & Company INC.1200 West Carmel Drive · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $356,805 disclosed · median 651 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsDwight Gossett13070 Abraham Run · Carmel, IN 46033 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $61 disclosed · median 127 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsGallagher Benefit Svcs INC650 East Carmel Drive, Suite 400 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $5,069 disclosed · median 713 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsMerrill W Schoenrock14721 Beacon Blvd · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $2,302 disclosed · median 2,088 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsPerformance Matters Associates11825 Pennsylvania St · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $168 disclosed · median 507 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsShephard Insurance LLC (Nfp)111 Congressional Blvd · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $68,444 disclosed · median 273 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsTic International Corporation11590 N. Meridian, Ste 600 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $15,686 disclosed · median 4,127 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filingsWharton Insurance & Financial Serv12735 Meeting House Rd #100 · Carmel, IN 46032 · Health and welfare plans2 plan filings · $1,491,750 disclosed · median 5,079 participantsNamed in Form 5500 filings
Comparing benefits brokers in Carmel? Ask each for a written description of every way it is paid, and read questions to ask your benefits broker.

Listed from DOL EBSA Form 5500 datasets — Schedule A Part 1, DOL EBSA Form 5500 datasets — Form 5500, DOL EFAST2 Form 5500 search. Order: most plan filings first — not a quality or price ranking — never paid. Is something wrong? Tell us.